Why the Government Should Not Run Healthcare
The FTC has issued an RFI (”Request for Information”) with regard to its idea to build a “Do Not Spam List” similar to the National Do Not Call Registry.
Umm, guys . . . Spam is already illegal. Enforce that law.
This would be exactly like the federal government providing a web site and toll free numbers where you could go sign up if you didn’t want to be a victim of identify theft.
“Just enter your name, address, date of birth, social security number, all credit card numbers — and we’ll pass out the information and tell everyone not to use it for improper means.”
Hello? Who thought that it would be a good idea to give a bunch of spammers a list and say, “Here’s a bunch of valid email addresses. Don’t spam these people.”
The National Do Not Call Registry is for people to opt-out of something that is otherwise legal. Spam is illegal in any case. Do we need to opt out of being burglarized next?
By the way, while we’re on the subject of Spam, the solution is simple. Let private people sue for every legitimate spam email they receive — just like the junk fax law. We all get junk faxes, but not nearly as many as we used to, and many junk faxers have literally gone out of business over all the people suing them. In this litigious society, letting people go into small claims court for $500 per email would solve the problem of U.S.-based spammers in a hurry.
Of course, spam needs to be carefully defined, and there should be penalties for frivolous suits — like where someone forgets that they did opt in to a list. But leaving it up to the FTC to enforce against only the worst offenders is no solution. Particularly when this is the same agency investigating a Do Not Spam list with a straight face.











